Joe Rogan Experience #2574 - Francis Foster & Konstantin Kisin · Aired Oct 31, 2026
The finding
What remains unresolved
Joe asks this as a question at 1:27, and the answer he gets is unsure. Parts of it match the Associated Press report: on October 25, 2026, Justice Cristiano Zanin, Lula's former lawyer, ruled three minutes before polls closed to keep them open two more hours. But AP says he acted on requests from both candidates. Lula's campaign cited bus problems in Sao Paulo and Salvador, and Flavio Bolsonaro's campaign cited heavy rain in the south, where he is favored. Lula won by nearly 4.4 million votes. The electoral court's president, who was appointed by Jair Bolsonaro, said the extension did not affect the result, while AP said it was unclear how many polling stations stayed open late. Nothing we found shows the extra two hours decided the race, but there is no full count of late votes here either, so the claim that it let Lula win stays unverified.
Read the supporting source · www.pbs.org ↗The context belongs here.
No separately verified on-air correction is recorded for this check. That is not a claim that nobody corrected it.
- Attribution
- Not independently confirmed in this record
- Editorial context review
- Not recorded; generated finding
- Coverage
- One selected claim from the episode
Revisions to this check
Oct 31, 2026
Previously: A former defense attorney for Lula was elected to the Supreme Court of Brazil and subsequently opened the polls for an additional two hours to enable Lula's victory. [Distorted]: Cristiano Zanin was Lula's lawyer before Lula appointed him (not elected him) to Brazil's Supreme Court in 2023, and on October 25, 2026 he ordered voting in the presidential runoff extended two hours at polling stations still open. The part saying this let Lula win does not hold up. Electoral court data show only about 35,500 votes were cast after the normal 5 p.m. close, while Lula won by about 4.43 million votes. Electoral court records showing millions of votes cast during the extension would make this wrong.
Now: Joe asks whether Lula's former lawyer extended voting by two hours and thereby enabled Lula to win. [Unverified]: Joe frames this as a question and asks whether it is accurate at 1:27; the reply is also tentative. The initial explanation offered exact post-5-p.m. votes and victory-margin figures through a secondary article. This pass did not independently establish those figures from the underlying 2026 election records, or establish that extended voting caused the outcome. The appointment, polling extension and causal claim must be checked separately. The full allegation stays unresolved.
Preserve the question and withhold an exact numerical rebuttal until its underlying election records are verified.
Evidence for the revision ↗Oct 31, 2026
Previously: Joe asks whether Lula's former lawyer extended voting by two hours and thereby enabled Lula to win. [Unverified]: Joe frames this as a question and asks whether it is accurate at 1:27; the reply is also tentative. The initial explanation offered exact post-5-p.m. votes and victory-margin figures through a secondary article. This pass did not independently establish those figures from the underlying 2026 election records, or establish that extended voting caused the outcome. The appointment, polling extension and causal claim must be checked separately. The full allegation stays unresolved.
Now: Joe asks whether Lula's former lawyer extended voting by two hours and thereby enabled Lula to win. [Unverified]: Joe asks this as a question at 1:27, and the answer he gets is unsure. Parts of it match the Associated Press report: on October 25, 2026, Justice Cristiano Zanin, Lula's former lawyer, ruled three minutes before polls closed to keep them open two more hours. But AP says he acted on requests from both candidates. Lula's campaign cited bus problems in Sao Paulo and Salvador, and Flavio Bolsonaro's campaign cited heavy rain in the south, where he is favored. Lula won by nearly 4.4 million votes. The electoral court's president, who was appointed by Jair Bolsonaro, said the extension did not affect the result, while AP said it was unclear how many polling stations stayed open late. Nothing we found shows the extra two hours decided the race, but there is no full count of late votes here either, so the claim that it let Lula win stays unverified.
Gemini pass lead, verified by Claude against the AP report on PBS: adds the sourced context Joe asked about (both campaigns requested the extension, the margin, the court president's statement) while keeping the question framing and the unverified verdict Codex chose.
Evidence for the revision ↗Challenge this finding or add context →